“I can’t believe you just did that. How do you do it? You should be teaching that shit," he says, eyes wide open.
When did I become so manipulative?
I look at the boy in front of me. His eyes, shining with admiration. He’s impressed by what he just saw. Hell, I’m impressed too. It shouldn’t be this easy.
I met Mark two, maybe three weeks ago at the premiere of his new movie. I liked him. Cute, tall, dark hair, big brown eyes, and a wicked, quirky sense of humor.
The director, a friend of mine, knew I had a bit of a crush on him, sat me next to Mark at the screening. Then, during one of the scenes, a whisper.
"That's me," he said about the silhouette of a naked man.
"Really?" I say more mischievously than surprised. The man on the screen is standing in a profile, he's, um... big.
"A-huh. The actor who was supposed to do that scene was sick that day, so they asked me to do it."
I tilt my head ever so slightly, "I can see why."
He laughs.
We had a couple of drinks that night at a bar, after the movie. I thought things were going well. There was no doubt in my mind I was taking him home. Then, out of the blue:
"Well, I really have to split. I have an early morning tomorrow," he said as he was getting up.
"You do?"
"Yes, but if you want I'd like we can exchange numbers?"
I called him a few days later but never heard from him. Two weeks later, a ring.
"Hey man, sorry about not calling. I keep getting confused, is it two days, or two weeks you're supposed to wait before calling someone back?"
I laugh.
"You're forgiven."
We met at Bowery Bar that night. He was there with his best-friend-straight-roommate, Jason. The three of us are talking, having a good time. Mark's flirting but not overtly. He's with someone, a straight guy. I keep hoping we could be alone but Jason, he won't leave.
"So, any cute girls you like around here?" I finally ask his friend, "You know, you're probably the only straight guy around. Easy. Like fish in a barrel."
The boy takes a look, sees a girl, zeros in on her. She's nothing spectacular, but I can see why she's attractive. She's a walking advertisement for milk. She's Elsie.
"You like her?" I ask.
He nods, but doesn't make a move. A shy one. The girl is chatting with a friend. Cute guy, looks like he just stepped off a bus from Jersey City.
A few steps, a tap on a shoulder, a friendly smile.
"What's your name?"
"I'm Cindy."
"Hi Cindy, I'm Ethan, nice to meet you. Can I tell you, you're beautiful."
"Oh, you're so sweet. This is my friend, Abe."
"Hi Abe, Ethan."
I focus back on her, "You're too cute."
"Not too bad yourself." she says. "If you were straight, I wouldn't kick you out of bed."
"Thanks."
"Except to fuck you on the floor."
I laugh. She's Jersey all the way, but she's funny.
"I'm so rude." I tell her. "This is my friend, Jason."
As if on cue, Jason moves in, there's a smile on his face. A grateful one.
I look at Mark, my eyes saying, "follow my lead."
"Abe, I'd like you to meet my friend Mark."
Mark says hi to the boy, still not following me. Then sees Jason and Cindy talking, chummy. He gets it. Coin, dropped.
Mark and I chat up Abe who tells us he's going to Rutgers University where he's studying public relations. He's got spiky black hair with faint honey-brown streaks, dark eyes and way too many gold chains around his neck. Somehow though, he pulls it off, he's still hot, in a Kiss-Me-Guido kind of way.
We're drinking. One, two, three, drinks. We're all hitting it off. I'm getting a bit wasted but that's okay because everything's going according to plan. Jason's with Cindy, and Mark and I have cornered her gay friend to give the straight boy enough time to charm the pants off her. Literally.
Then I do what I sometimes do when I get drunk, I get friendlier. Abe is close, real close. His hand is around my waist, he's talking to me. I can feel his breath on my ear. That's when my hand slides down, just a bit, enough to grab his left cheek.
"Dude. What's that all about?" He said as he stepped back, "do we need to take this outside?"
For a moment I thought he was joking. Take what outside? Then, I realize. Me and my stupid hands have somehow stumbled on the closeted Jersey-guy. One minute he's talking about checking out the Pier Dance, the next he's defending some bruised honor, arms flailing every which way.
I look at Mark, he has that, what-the-fuck look on his face.
"Dude, sorry about that, wasn't serious," I tell Abe.
"Do we need to take it outside?"
He's not letting go.
"Man, I'm sorry, really. Didn't mean to offend you."
He's still not convinced.
I look at Mark, he's actually worried.
"See this guy here?" I point at Mark, "he's my boyfriend."
Mark, panic.
"You don't have to worry," I tell him. "Really, didn't mean anything by it."
And that was it. Somehow I found the right words, the right code to defuse the situation. Like air out of a tire, hiss all around. Abe's eyes softened a bit, his shoulders, down ever so slightly.
"Really?"
He looks at Mark.
"Is he really your boyfriend?"
"Yes, we'll be together three years in August," Mark tells him. He's good. He says it so quickly, so naturally, the guy actually believes him. He walks away.
For a moment, silence. Then Mark, laughing, a big laugh, one that comes bellowing out. He's seems impressed by the way I handled it all, how I never quite lost my cool.
I look at him. He's not mad, just amused.
"Three years in August, huh?"
"Yeah, but I'm thinking of dumping you. You're fresh."
We get another drink, forget about the boy, the "altrication." We're having fun. I notice Mark's more attentive, his body's closer, almost touching mine. This experience has brought us together, shattered whatever ice was left to be broken.
Then, just as I'm about to suggest we go back to my place. Abe, in front of me, madness in his eyes. He's angry. He's also slightly drunk.
"Do we need to take this outside?"
Shit. Not again. I make a promise to never touch another ounce of vodka for as long as I live, and if I do, to never, ever grab someone's butt without their explicit permission. In writing if possible.
"No man, remember? We already settled this. We're cool."
I don't know what else to do. I'm actually appealing to his drunken sense of recollection.
"I feel like we should take it outside," the boy insists.
Mark steps in, puts himself between me and Abe. He's about to say something but I stop him.
"No it's okay." I say. "Abe and I obviously need to talk."
"Are you sure?"
"No, not really."
I follow Abe a few steps, then he stops, turns around, looks at me. Hell, loose.
"Dude, I need to know, do you grab everyone's ass like that?"
There's no way to get out of this one, I might as well go out with a bang.
"No, No." I say all horrified. "Like THAT only the cute ones."
I'm waiting to see his reaction. I'm getting ready to fight. Instead, a smile on his face. He's maybe a bit crazy, but he's still got a sense of humor.
"You're cool bro."
Sigh. Relief. My heart descending back from my throat to my chest. Bullet, dodged.
We go back to to Mark and Cindy who are waiting, like contestants on game show, to see which one of us comes out, which one of us has been eliminated.
Mark looks at me all confused.
"How is that possible?" he asks when we show up, Abe's arm around my neck. "A second ago he was about to hit you!"
The four of us chat a bit. Then, just as everyone's about to leave, Abe slips me his number.
"Call me sometime," he says. He's drunk, and something tells me, not so straight.
Mark looks at me. Stunned.
"I can’t believe you just did that. How do you do it? You should be teaching that shit," he says.
At this point I'm too drunk to go home with anyone. I say good night, get into a cab, head home.
The next morning, a message from Mark.
"That's clearly the most amazing thing I've ever seen."
I laugh, then text back, "You CLEARLY haven't seen me naked."